Nostalgia is bullshit.
- Read the strongest case for it
- Read the strongest case against it
- Wrote the first draft
- Rewriting until it holds up here now
- Off the table and published
I take one provocative statement at a time, read the strongest case for it and against it, and write down where I landed. Then the floor is yours.
Piece no. 07
There is always one piece in progress. This is the one I'm arguing with right now.
Waiting their turn
no deadline. it's done when it holds up.
The six elements
Critical thinking is six separate skills, and a piece can be good at five and still fall over. Every opinion here has to get all six right before it leaves the table.
What exactly are you saying?
The whole claim fits in one sentence, and a stranger gets it on the first read. If I can't say it plainly, I don't understand it yet.
It fails whenyou have to read a line twice to find the point.
Says who? Show me.
Every big claim stands on something you can check: a study, a number, a real example. Sounding sure is not a source.
It fails whenthe only proof is that everyone knows it.
How does this follow?
No leaps. Each paragraph follows from the one before it, so you can trace the path from the first line to the last.
It fails whena conclusion turns up that nothing led to.
What would the other side say?
The strongest opposing view, stated fairly, before I answer it. Beating a weak version of the other side proves nothing.
It fails whenthe people who disagree all sound foolish.
Why do you believe that?
Every opinion rests on something taken for granted. I name the one my argument leans on most, so you can decide whether you share it.
It fails whenthe argument only works if you already agree.
I've heard this. What's yours?
At least one angle I didn't borrow. If a piece only repeats what has been said already, it didn't need writing.
It fails whenyou could have guessed every paragraph.
Meet the host
I'm a creative director in Ahmedabad. My day job is building brands at Tikz Media. This club is where I practise thinking.
Every piece here starts as a statement I'm not sure about. I read both sides, pick one, and rewrite until the argument holds up. What you read is where I landed. It is biased on purpose, and it is never my final word.